Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.

 

Texas judge: Search warrants can be obtained based on predictions of future crimes

Published time: December 18, 2013 18:04
Edited time: December 19, 2013 19:22
AFP Photo / Tom Penningto

AFP Photo / Tom Penningto

Police in Texas may now obtain a search warrant based on “a prediction of a future crime,” according to a dissenting judge on the state’s criminal appeals court.

The ruling by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals came last week, ending a controversial case in which police searched a house before obtaining a warrant but were still able to present the confiscated evidence during a trial.

The incident began during the summer of 2010, when police in Parker County, Texas, staked out Michael Fred Wehrenberg’s home for a month. According to the Dallas Observer, authorities allegedly received a tip from a confidential informant stating Wehrenberg and his associates were “fixing” to cook meth in the home. Without obtaining a search warrant, they walked into the home and arrested the people inside.

It was only after arrests were made that police sought out the warrant necessary to confiscate the meth-making material in the home, including boxes of pseudoephedrine, stripped lithium batteries, and other items. On the warrant application, however, police declined to mention that they had actually been in the house prior to obtaining authorization for the search, mentioning only the informant who tipped them off.

During Wehrenberg’s trial, his attorney argued the confiscated material was inadmissible due to the fact that police seized it illegally. The judge overruled this request, saying federal “independent source doctrine” allows such evidence when a third party – the unnamed informant – tells police about it beforehand.

As a result, Wehrenberg pleaded guilty to one count of possession and another count of intent to manufacture. He was sentenced to five years in prison.

The Second Court of Appeals then overturned the trial judge’s decision, but ultimately the Court of Criminal Appeals agreed with the original ruling. As the Observer reported, the majority opinion written by Judge Elsa Alcala stated that while Texas law prohibits illegally obtained evidence to be submitted, federal precedent allows it if first confirmed by an independent third party.

One justice, however, did not agree. In the dissent, Judge Lawrence Meyers wrote that the only reason police decided to apply for the warrant is because they had previously entered the house illegally.

“Had the officers entered the home and found the occupants only baking cupcakes, the officers would not have bothered to then obtain the warrant at all,” Meyers wrote, according to the Observer. “It was only after unlawfully entering and finding suspicious activity that they felt the need to then secure the warrant in order to cover their tracks and collect the evidence without the taint of their entry.”

Meyers also dismissed the idea that the informant’s tip was actually confirmation by a third party, writing that it was merely a prediction.

“Search warrants may now be based on predictions of the commission of future crimes,” the judge wrote.

Comments (35)

 

Regula 30.01.2014 13:35

This isn't law anymore at all, this is a totalitarian clamp down on the people.

 

Casualty Beats 25.12.2013 21:58

why not just move the police station into my bed room then they can fine me 500 $ every time i jerk off i mean really the issue here is a legal system that has become a virus they will take every thing they can and its really scary that we allow other people to have this kind of power that has no checks or restrictions

 

Michael Hicks 25.12.2013 21:25

Whats to prevent cops from planting evidence to make arrests? This law needs to be repealed asap, if you let these scumbags take an inch they'll go a mile, just wait and see.

View all comments (35)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

OK

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

X

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us

Follow us