Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.


Independent panel denounces ‘chilling’ NSA program as illegal, demands end

Published time: January 23, 2014 14:42
Reuters/ Larry Downing

Reuters/ Larry Downing

An independent review board has labeled NSA hoarding of phone data ‘illegal’, adding that while it poses a serious threat to civil liberties, it was unable to find a “single instance” of a threat to the US where the program made any difference.

The Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board (PCLOB) released an acerbic report stating that the statute upon which the NSA program was based – Section 215 of the Patriot Act – does not “provide an adequate basis to support this program.” A pre-release was seen by both the New York Times and Washington Post.

PCLOB is an independent agency which was established by Congress in 2004, having been a recommendation by the 9/11 commission. It is intended to advise the executive branch of government on matters of privacy and civil liberties, related to terrorism, and ensure that Americans’ rights are not infringed upon in the establishment of more stringent anti-terrorism measures.

The program has a “chilling effect on the exercise of First Amendment rights,” on account of the revelations of relations and connections between individuals and groups, the report further stated. US citizens have constitutional rights to free speech, association and privacy.

While US President Barack Obama gave a speech on Friday saying that he thought the NSA database should be taken out of the hands of the government, he did not call for a stop to the program. However, the PCLOB opposed any legal mandate on the companies to retain any data for longer than they currently do.

In addition to the infringement of first amendment rights, the report noted the apparently complete ineffectualness of the program in the hunt for terror suspects.

“We have not identified a single instance involving a threat to the United States in which the telephone records program made a concrete difference in the outcome of a counterterrorism investigation,” it noted. “Moreover, we are aware of no instance in which the program directly contributed to the discovery of a previously unknown terrorist plot or the disruption of a terrorist attack.”

The 238 page text cited examples of times when the collection of phone records proved useless. The panel had cited 12 separate cases while making their conclusion, including the 2009 plot to bomb the New York City subway.

However, the panel itself was divided – two of its five members concluded that if the program was modified to accommodate additional privacy protections, it should continue, the newspapers said.

Revelations as to the extent of NSA surveillance of its own population – and on a global level – emerged via former NSA contractor and whistleblower Edward Snowden in June last year. The exposures have caused divisions in Congress as to the legality and value of the program, as well as inciting a severe public backlash about the ethics of the program.

Comments (5)


Marcus Jones 23.01.2014 23:42

Okay, so what about Google? Shouldn't Google's violations of our privacy be illegal? If you have a problem with how the NSA has violated our privacy, then you should also have a problem with how Google is destroying our privacy. Personally, I think everyone should start using privacy-based sites such as DuckDuckGo, Ravetree, HushMail, etc. The NSA is different because we don't really have a choice there, but we do have the freedom to choose whether or not we use Google, Facebook, etc.


Gary Snyder 23.01.2014 19:01

The law-abiding, constitution understanding, freedom enjoying American citizens are in a cold war with a long in the making corrupt group who believes they are the aforementioned. The balance of control and power are about to be seen. If the NSA stands it is a clear indicator the US of A is no longer what it was originally intended to be. No further observation required.


Gary David 23.01.2014 18:50

Avis71 23.01.2014 17:35

impeach Obama, Vote for Bernie Sander or Ron Paul


vote for Jesse Ventura if we can get him on the ballot, he is the only one who is not afraid to do the dance required with the criminals in charge and their lackeys
(most politicians)

View all comments (5)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or



Show password


or Register

Request a new password


or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:


or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile



New password

Retype new password

Current password



Follow us

Follow us